Scaring the Internet since 2006 (and currently replicating via Facebook), the "true" story of Carmen Winstead:
About 6 years ago in Indiana, Carmen Winstead was pushed down a sewer opening by 5 girls in her school, trying to embarrass her in front of her school during a fire drill. When she didn't submerge the police were called. They went down and brought up 17 year old Carmen Winstead's body, her neck broken from hitting the ladder, and then the side concrete at the bottom. The girls told everyone she fell... They believed them.
Comments
I don’t no if she was pushed down a sewer or not but i for sure no that the text every one is soo freaked out about is not true. I got it b4 i could text so i couldn’t send it and nothing ever happened.
Thank You! I got it 2 and nothing ever happened. It’s all lies. Nobody who is dead can come back to life unless God brings them and you cant haunt people if your alive. Its all lies and if I get that mail one more time…
i think she did get pushed but im not sure some 1 thats dead can slither up the drain or pour out of my and come all the way from india and get me it just seems like to much work but i do feel srry for her if she did really get pushed!!!
i know right this is so stupid. some of my friend just send this to make sure they do die!!!!
it is real thers a news story on her the text isnt real.
I so agree but what i dont understand is that those five girls would do such a thing and i so believe that it wouldnt be much work and if it was it would be worth it! RIP Carmen
Actually, there was never a girl who died named Carmen Winstead on the news. There was no news found about it check it out on snopes
i totally agree, i got an e-mail saying all that stuff and i couldn’t forward it because my internet dropped out. it has been a month and nothing had happened.
lmao that funny how like nohting happened but everyone keeps like freeking out over it like seriosuly calm down you tihnk somethings gonna happen over a forward and i have gotten it 2x i got it one 2 years ago and then just now and nothing happened 2 years ago.
Buahha Im not Deadd ! Eitherr
IDK about her beign real and all is true or not but the text going around isnt true. a couple years ago when i couldnt text i got it and of course couldnt send it and guss what nothing ever happened soo dont get all freaked out if you cant send it cause nothing happens!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
ya i dont kno y everyone is soo scared
tht is soooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo freakey i beleved it nd i need to go pee but im scared to go into the bathroom!
Yeah I also dno y people r so scared…and people send a text all ova,I ddnt pass it on nd nothing happnd sooo
? Wht if u got tha txt nd u culd txt do u send it or no im not sure if its tru but if it wuz i wuld b carmens friend nd wuld stick up 4 hur nd idk wht to do im freaked out i need an answer
wts are you saying good god
Dude his sh** is so fake its just a lil story lil kids like to send around tryin to scare someone..its a bunch of fake storys put together in word nd o got it didnt forward it nd im still fine
i dont know whats wrong with you people nore what happend to her,but im only 12 ,ive siriusley only been once in my life,and beliv it or not ,i just pist my pants,,,i whant to hear this from a person that was there.Names and proof,when were how who!
I’ll tell you what to do and what i believe just TRUST IN GOD when someone dies he does not let anyone come back to haunt you and something else my family is Christain people and i am a 19 year old Minister for the Lord jesus christ and we as in my family and me dont believe in that stuff but another thing people need to realize they are SPIRITS out there like EVIL SPIRITS THAT COME FROM SATAN AND YES THEY CAN COME AFTER YOU AND TRY TO GET IN YOU BUT WHEN PEOPLE DIE GOD WILL NOT LET THEM COME BACK HERE TO THE EARTH AND HAUNT YOU OR ANYBODY. SO BEFORE I GET OFF HERE I WANT TO LEAVE YOU WITH SOMETHING OKAY TATI THE BIBLE SAYS ” GOD DOES NOT PUT A SPIRIT A FEAR UPON YOU BUT OF PEACE AND OF A SOUND MIND.
GOD BLESS YOU ALWAYS
MINISTER WESLEY
DAVIS
thanks
It isn’t real. Last night, me and my friends did chants to resurrect her, and we made fun of it. We’re still alive.
Carmen was pushed i beilive for story u can to0 beilive her story
i recently recieved an email saying that carmen will get me if i dont forward a message. I havent done it. Im seriously freaked out. Ive pooed myself many times today and night is drawing closer. Shes meant to be getting me tonight and breaking my neck and pulling my face skin off then throwing me down the sewer. HELP?!
i bet carmen was well fit when she was alive. Not that i discriminate against dead people. I hope she flashes her tits for me before i die!!!
lol dude is that all you can think about?
WHAT THE HELL?
It is not true. I got the foward like three months ago and I never sent it to anybody else. And I am still alive and in bery good shape. I believe that she may be read but the fwd is not. Idk why people fall for that stoupid stuff. And I really don’t understand why u would get freaked out because its not real.
i agree w all of you and toby is a major jerk
is this true people in other website like weeworld is typing that telling the whole story and threaing people if they dont send it to 10 people by midnight she going to get you in the shower toilet or sewer
they pushed her poor carmen winstead she died by 5 girlz i hate that is soooooooooooooooooooooo mean
I REally hate those girls they annoy me i just want to be there for carmen when it all happned i do believe in it
i am real
Your kiddin me!
carmen hey wats up um i tink ur story is true nd they did push u down thurr so just letting u kno
i dont believe in this crap any mor
Lol I like the comment by “Carmen winstead”
haha I got this txt a while back and I forwarded it. But honestly, the pic with the txt looked exactly like my friend Sabrina and I’m pretty sure it was:) this is a bunch of mumbo jumbo, but it even freaked me out. I know it isn’t real, but itz easy to get sucked into it…idk, believe wut u want. Just forward it to freak somebody else out at least! Lol
Shelby: we dont know if its true but one of my friends got hurt because she didnt believe it and didnt post it SO ALL WE ASK OF U IS TO POST IT SO IT DOESNT HAPPEN TO U. Camila: oh, and one more thing, i got stuck in a sewer n a half n hour l8er i got found! IF YOU DONT REPOST IT… SHE WILL COME OUT OF THE SHADOWS N FIND YOU! joking bout the she will find you thing, but im serious bout the stuck in the sewer thing! haha
People getting freak out for this kind of txt msg is just pathetic.. -.-” bunch of losers…
don’t make me mad……
Say 1 more nasty/non believing crap.. and i swear.. you will wake up in a sewer.. just like me…
so u r still alive ur not even dead u liar
wow i believe every thing you say an i think its true u didnt just fall i kno 4 a fact that you were pushed and if i were ur friend no 1 would touch u or me n i jus wish u were still here an it feels lik ur already my bff
Omg.
This is soo sad.
What kind of people would do this ?
Like seriously .
Carmen sounds like a very nice person .
Those girls were just jealous or somthing !
I just got it and im freaked out cuz I cant send it from my ipod . But I promise I will send it tommorrow when I go on my computer (:
You are amazing Carmen !
I wish I could of helped .
Please give me a chance to send it before you visit me tonight !
I am terribly sorry .
I just got this fwd this is bs
its ture my friend was walking by a sewer and then got drag in but it was closed when we found him his legs and arms were broke and we saw a figure in the water we still havent herd from the doctor he says he says it may be years untill the recovery and he is it a state of shock i am so freakin scared because i got the message and when i tried to send it it didnt work its like she wants me to die help me please
hello i haven’t killed any of u because there are so many people i hav to kill next in my list is Caroline Borrero
i hav just killed caroline borrero
u didnt deserve it im srry
allison mayhugh is next
and her friends
hi i read your story i think it is sad.
nooooo
everybody listen this is true my daughter was killed
i saw the message and i sent it so that i would live and i did but she didnt oooooohhhhhh my doughter
omg carmen winstead is real…she jux sed she was gone kill sumone and yo daughter died
This is so fun to see. I love the fake comments especially the ones from “Carmen Winstead”. I find it funny how some are in caps and some aren’t. I also find it hilarious how a dead person can post comments. I’ll tell u guys tommorow morning when I finish dying.
I don’t beleive the txt but i beleive she was killed.One of my friends sisters knew one of Carmens friends and said it was 100% true, so i beleive it.I’m sooo sorry Carmen!!!I hope those girls payed for what they did!!!!!
me too srry for u deth kid are mean too me to
omg i got the chain mail and ive been lookin it up. like y would she wanna kill u if ur sad dat she died and she didnt do the chain so y would she kill us i dunt feel like goin 2 india though lol XD
i think carmen did get pushed down the sewr. the story sounds real and i feel bad for poor carmwn yet i know she’s still on earth
that text message made me scared but now i no there not true when i saw the picture of her i was very scared
This “Story” Isn’t true I’ve done all the rescearch, I’ve reread all the post and watched all the youtube videos. IT IS NOT TRUE.
Carmen Winstead is a made up story that was posted as a bulliten on Myspace by 3 girls looking to see how many people would add them. It’s all fake. You have nothing to worry about. I’ve gotten that forwards 17 times and I am perfectly fine.
The story is super true. Carmen was pushed. But the forward thing isn’t. I didn’t send it or post it. And yet I’m still fine. Carmen must’ve been a wonderful person. She looks pretty and beautiful. I’m sorry, Carmen. I hope we can be friends.
i think this is hecka funny people listen how in hell is a dead chick going to leave a comment is she a ghost or some crap omg this is just a pill of crap if u think this is real ur crazy
i got the fwd after i left the comment yesterday i didnt fwd it and look im still alive omg why didnt carmen winstead get me is she afriad or some crap gosh some people are editiots
WOW, i do think she was killed and i’m scared to take a shower so i take the fastest shower i can now
this is not true!!!!!! i have recieved this message and nothing has ever happened when i didnt send it. Kids dont be scared!!!!!
Seriously, it’s jst a story that some kids made up
If you don’t post it, nothing will ever happen
carmen im sooooooo sorry but dont kill me im soo pritty and cant die yet i just got a wonderful boyfriend named josh fin …….. I LOVE U CARMEN EVEN MORE THAN MY NEW BF
i personaly feel bad for carmen, deeply. its sad because she died at 17 years old… and she had a horrible death. neck snapped, land on her face, and face torn off. like wow!And the deaths of these five girls and pratically the whole class[the ones that did not believe that she had been pushed by those girls] its not a coincidence. it cant be! also, of the same deaths of them.
This story is like the abc family show pretty little liers…I mean there were five girls who were bffs nd one died that started to torture the lives of the other four girls nd they started to recieve weird texts
i think her mom killed those girls and toby is a perv 4 reals
i think she was pushed in a swer i think,poor camen …well who ever pushed her is guna regrat it
i think its real just not the text and the amber girl is shelfish and selfcenterd cuz she said im soo pritty and im pretty sure shes wrong. and she spelled “PRETTY” wrong.
Lmao!!!!!!-
..
i dont believe in this nonsense.. and if carmen was really real.. god would be on my side
i could believe she was pushed by some jealous girls at her skool.. but not the fact that she would come and kill u in he sewer.. i got this msg 2day.. and i would lik to see if im styll alive tmrw.. ill save this page on favourites.. and then return tmrw
lol!.. il even reply .. again
lik seriously ppl.. get real!..
nd btw.. how do u “google” it ?? :S
i beleve ur stry carmen!!! please dont hurt me!!im 2 young 2 die!!!!im only 13!!!please!! i sent the e-mail!!! im sorry for what happened!!!!those gurls were wrong!!!
this isn’t very freaky i’ve read it like 5 times now
be sorry for me I won’t come and kill you if u be sorry for me
then kill me already im still waiting im not dead yet hahh and i dont fell sorry for u cause this is a lie and u just put ur name on there im not sooooo scared and all u guys r retared u beileve this this is just non sense lol !!!
im am not scared ok and u guys are so retarted beileve ing this crap and i dont fell sorry for u so kill and u never did hhahh!!!!!
freaky but not that freaky
who ever didn’t send it i’m coming for you i swear
hey guys this is freaky
love all my fans
shut up i’m coming for you
:,) weird
ok
i got the text from my friend alissa (hi alison mark i think i know u) i dont think the story is fake but if u dont send the text nuthin happens. i know….because i sent it to NOONE
*illy-hubby-boo i love u 67*
true story of awesomeness
hunting
six years ago carmen winstead was pusheddown a sewer opening by 5 classmates trying to embarrass her during a fire drill.when she didnt come back up,the police were called.the girls told everyone she “fell”.and they believed them. FACT:two months later jared morgan read this and didnt send it.when he went to take a shower,he heard laughter,freaked out and ran to his cell phone to send it.he went to sleep that night perfect.5hours later his mom waz awaking to a loud noise to find jaredgone. he waz found in a sour face neck broken and face peeled send to 10 ppl……or dont
i wish they would kill justin bieber
i heard there’s a similar chain letter written about me…
and yes, if i wasn’t all loving, i’d shiv beiber myself…
first of all carmen won’t come after you i got the msg read it like five times, laughed because her classmates pushed her and went right to sleep and im still here laughing… let that girl come to my bedroom at night i would push her ass down the sewer again, don’t come after me cus you have some messed up classmates she should have killed them for revenge!!!
Okay you guys are funny!
lol for the jesus thing but i didnt send the message and everything on google says its real but i think it may be real, but i dont believe shes gonna kill you. i believe in ghosts and demons and stuff but thats just bull crap people are telling you cause i never send chain messages saying youre gonna die at midnight if you dont send this to ten people but im still alive so WHAT NOW
im so srry Carmen dont kill me im only 12 and i have and long way to go in life!!!!
So true it actually did happen in my hometown of toronto a guy went down a swer to find his girfriend locket that some girls had thrown down there. After Eli moore didnt come up the kids went to get and adult….the adult then went down the cold n damp sewer to go and check if the kid was alright..the adult later came up with a bloody phone in his hand and it had the message of carmen winstead he was about to send it when it his face was cut up and hiseyes where tooken out. TRUE story look up eli moore in toronto
sad
poor Carmen she didn’t deserve to die. she sounds like a good person. if i was her friend i wouldn’t let those girls touch her.i got the fwd yesterday and i sent it to 14 people. no 20 people!.!. i looked her up and i believe that she was pushed down a sewer. i was scared so i sent it to everyone.she is real so back off and stop saying that shes not and ryan it is possible her ghost leaving comments!!!!!
This isn’t real. I read it and i didn’t hear laughter out of the shower sink or toilet. Nothing has gone wrong so far. However legends have been based of fact. If it is true then her spirit may have hunted down the girls who pushed her. But she will not kill you if you don’t send a texy
;] WEll i got the text today i never sent it im living and ill wait till the morning Carmen can SMD
that is insane. i think her friends were very sad but those girls are liars
Carmen I am so sorry those girls are so mean:( I did not forward the text but I do think Carmen is real and I feel so bad for her. I know the text is fake because I mean really would she actually want to do the same awful thing that was done to her to everybody else?
Dnt worry carmen I believe ur one of the only forwards dat r true I forwarded it
yea its real
ALL OF YOU RH LAMES YOUR STUPID BT MAYBE SHE DID GET PUSHED DOWN THE SEWER BT SHE WILL NOT COME FOR YOU! LYK WTF OMG YALL EXAGGERATIN HARDD!!!!!!!
omg wow all of da fwd & chain letters are not REAL SO STOP BEING little girlz & grow up !!!!!!!
I don’t know if the myh about the coming to get u is real or not but I do think the story of her death is real if any1 didn’t send the message and is ok send me a message or a couple from multiple days maybe
P.S. I feel so bad for Carmen those other girls were just jerks. They were jealous of her swagger
Poor Carmen… I got the message yesterday but only sent to 10 ppl….. man Im sorry Carmen but please…dont come for me… i dont have much friends either and i no how u felt…. please, when i die, i hope you become my afterlife best friend…….
Sorry fr not sendig it Carmen plz dont come after me im onnly 12. i dont have twenty ppl in my contacts i dont even have 10 for crying out loud ive got a brother whos 5 i think he would miss me, a lot
dear carmen,
you sound so nice! i cant believe some girls would do that to you. you look really pretty in the picture someone forwarded me (: lol nooo homoo. but im sooooooo freaked out right now! im one of those kids whos momma only gives them 150 texts per month, and I DONT KNOW WHAT TO DO! im sooooo freakedd, and my mom HATES me forwarding them, but i did anyways just in case. welll, im sorry to what happened to you, carmen. i hope those 5 girls die in HE double hockey stickk. (:
xoxo,
kelley
haii carmen!
im soooo sorry for what happened to youu! i beeeelive your story, and i sent it. so i was reading the comments, and ppl are saying you have to send it to 10 people. my fwd sad to fwd it to TWENTY people… you think its a typo?
don’t be mean to ppl that r dead when they can’t defend themselfs bitches and if u want to ressurect ppl be nice too them or tey will haunt u down and kill u if i dont get there first…
i say it is true about carmen but not the fwd thing but the thing is that i got the fwd at 2:00 in the morning and i had my lights on but then they turned off and my phone vibrated and thats when i got the txt msg but i got scared when i read it becuze it was all darksoo i decided to fwd it then when i fwd it the lights turned on so next morning i ask my mom if the elictricity was out and she said no so i thnk carmen waz in my room waiting 4 me to send the msg well anyways i dont know if i should belive it or not
well i’ll find out if it is true tonight xD lol send it 20 people, please, my phone won’t let me send something to that many people
so i’m dead the moment i read that? xD
but i think the story could be real and i feel bad for the girl i really do, just like with bloody mary, but i doubt if she was really a nice innnocent girl that she would go kill people because they didn’t send a freaking forward message?! that’s just not right -_-
look you can put carmen winstead in the name thing its THAT simple dont go scaring the living out of people let carmen rest in peace she deserves that stop making up lies saying shes going to killl u like they killed her its just cruel and childish seriously guys!?!
so you are not carmen winsomethingsomething are you now?
ok this chick is a creeper i couldnt go to bed last night i woke up at midnight and turned on all the lights in my house!!!
Carmen winstead, why are you stilll ALIVE?????
Carmen Winstead, why are you still ALIVE?????
so you aren’t carmen winsomethingsomething afterall
I do belive the Carmen Winstead story is real. I mean Its possible. I think she must have been realy nice and those girls who pushed her are jerks. I have lots of bulies at school so I feel bad for her. Once in my 6 period choir class a girl named cecila took my backpack and put it under the risers while i was on my teachers computer. I stayed 20 minutes after school trying to get it out. Another time, we were joking around with a matiachi locker with no lock that was behind the risers. We were seeing if we could fit in it so my friend went and fit then another girl went in she fit. I went in and they put a pencil on the door so I couldnt get out all of them were laughing at me while my only chioir freind was in the bathroom. I was calling my teachers name and banging on the locker and he finnaly let me out. I got back at cecila later during a choir party by putting chips in her hoodie.
yea i nko wat youh mean but i have a bullie too and shes not so nice to meah but i really dont want to say any names here but she was like nice to meah wen i 1st came to my school btw i go to whittney but yea and she was like youh can come sit over here and stuff so i did and she was like asking me some questions well one day she was like was r u stearing at nd sh e like started rumors bout meh and stuff so i started one bout her but i fell really bad bout wat i say to her i say that she was having sex wit her dad and her dad got her pregnet so yea but now we are friends but i have a nother one shes not that bad but she can talk the talk but she cant fight her own battlesher name is hope she gives meh rude looks all the time so i do it back but if u ever met meh im not that bad really im really nice and im a lover not a fighter but i dnot c y she has a problem wit meh i dont hurt no one that she knos and i dont like still her friends at all i mean wats the whole point well thats all wat i have to say i hope that people understand that fighting and stuff gets youh in iss or jail or somtin like that well yea hope u can understand my problem like i understood urs thankz
yeshh people this is true ma friend died like three day laters!das why dnt be so sure of yoohr self & every thing well happen on its time trust me.its jst some thing that magectily happens…some times this lil textes that yooh get are real!!!
I got the text message on Monday and I didn’t even read it. I just glimpsed through it but that was all. I read it the next day and it TOTALLY freaked me out. I only had 10 contacts and I was expected to foward it to 20 people. Yeah I don’t think so. I’ll admit i couldn’t couldn’t sleep. I was pretty scared. The next day I researched this and there was no police record of this. THIS IS NOT REAL!!! I didn’t foward it and I’m still here. Whoever started this crap has no life!!!
OH C’MON, PEOPLE, GROW UP!!!
yall kant be serious ?? lyk 4 real ! its a freakin chain letter ! made by ppl who have NO LIFE && those of yu who continue tu forward it are jus as DUMB as those who made it ! those stories are as real as yu make em out tu b ! GROW UP PPL ! qet a hobby or sumthin !
I’m still here people. Didn’t send it and im still here. Don’t be afraid people. IT’S FAKE!!!
i just got the text and it kinda freaked me out so i juat wanted to make aureit mot true
i feel sorry for her and whoever did that is mean.
Yep still here.
Wow. I was worried for a min…but Carmen, rest
In peace. For all others, let’s make the opportunity
Of making friends, my e-mail for facebook n
Myspace…mr_aguilar2010@yahoo.com.
i did not believe this and ignored the forward but then
i fell off my bed and broke my ankle BUT SILL NOT TRUE
this all just a bunch of crap
oh and if carmen was real (which she isnt)
I would want her to kill justin bever(or whoever)
Anybody could write any name here whats soever seriously? If i was even Paris Hilton would i spend my time lookin this up? I got this txt 3 times with 3 different pictures of “Carmen”
First shes White then Spanish then shes Black. if this was real i would have been dead a LONG TIME AGO… and these deaths because of the text would DOMINATE news stations.
Plz get a clue…
The people that pushed her should get killed
I hope Carmen rests in peace. I feel extremely sorry for her though…I believe she is in heaven wit Jesus now…if the text is real, i only have like 6 contacts in my phone…so i sent it to them
Okay I’m really sorry about what happenrd Carmen I would never do that to anyone in fact I’m sure I’d be your friend I swear I’m sure those girls were just jealous!!! I believe completely!!!! Rest in peace.
oh my gosh when I got this mge I looked her up and started crying I felt so bad for that poor girl I cldnt beleive someone thought it would be fun to push her down a sewer opening but I fwded the mge cuz it did kinda scare me
omg you just cant make fun of her she got murdered and some of you probly dnt even care i dnt know her but i feel sorry 4 her and you should to so make fun i dnt care but think of that wen she comes 4 you
STILL HERE!!!!!
i only got the msg today and when its the first thing you read in the morning it is freaky, freaky enough to make me google it and end up on here, but lets be honest, WHAT A LOAD OF SHIIITE!!!!!
They pushed her down a sewer
You ppl have no life…
Well i donot believe this crap because i got this txt like 7 diferent times and all of them had different pics if “carmen” and if u guys think that shes really going to “get” u…. Well then why hasnt she “got” all the other ppl who didnt send this????? Hmmmm???? And i seriously think yall should stop haten on justin bieber… How can u hate on somebody if u dnt no ‘em????
So i hve got this fwd like 7 times all of them hve had different pics of ” carmen” and i didnot send it bc its bull and if she was sooo real why hasnt she killed anyone tht didnt send it??? And i seriously think yall should stop haten on justin bieber… How can u hate on someone tht u dnt no???
Sooo i guess this fwd is going bck around?!?! Wow sooooo stupid just sayin and i agree stop haten on jb!!!! Lol:) and this fwd has been goin arnd for yrs comon guys nothin has happen to u yet!!!
I DONOT beleive in her!!!! Stupid
Crazzzy cant beleive yall are bck on this just bc i said some thin
Camren I didn’t send ur forward but I nerley Freud about whenthose stupid girls pushed u down that man hole sorry
That iz sad that she died.:( I am vry sad and freaked out!! PoorCarmen. She actually does sound nice. Now scared 2 go 2 the restroom!!! I want to b her friend. I dont understand y those girls pushed her down. But whoever they r , I HATE THEM!!! I would never would push anybody down a sewer.Well now i got 2 go!!! = l
Hey,
Whoever acts like Carmen ,is stupid.But , kinda wierd.I wish people would beleive .I wish she were alive so i can be her friend .If that wierd person that acts like Carmen leaves me a message well…UR WEIRD!!! And if u say that u r gunna kill me? U cant! U dont no where i live!!!
Bye. I will leave another comment tomorow
Hey Yo
Its me again i was just waiting 4 “Carmen Winstead” 2 leave me a message. And i as reading all the comments and i would never kill Justin Bieber .FYI i was Justin Biebers #1 Fan!!!well i promise i will leave another comment After that fake “Carmen Winstead” leaves 1!!!: )
$un$h!ne
B3n@//¥
thats so sad that 5 girls pushed the poor girl down the sewer… just because she was new and that they wanted to embarass her. but who ever didnt believe that the 5 girls pushed her in the sewer carmen went for revenge and killed them all the same way that she died. but if u scream for help she would take ur face skin off .. i believe in the story..and people say that her story is still here and still haunts people who ever dont believe in the story or that the 5 girls pushed her… and why would people say that she fell.. who falls in the sewer ? she was pushed.. arent u sad and feel bad for her… what if that happened to anyone that says its fake or that she fell in the sewer.. she was pushed ohkayy by 5 rude girls..
Carmen we are sorry for you that should’nt of happened to you we are a little scared and we sent the message 3 times if we ever die we want to be your bffs in afterlife
-Amber Lynsey Audra-
Carmen we feel so bad for you and feel really sad for you it never should of happened to you i hope you except that we sent it over the amount and we got it from a couple of people. And everybody who says you arent real they just dont belive so carmen we are so very sorry for you and we are a little scared please dont come for us we are just girls we feel so bad for you and you are the coolest ever!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
im pretty sure this story is true becuz i got the forward but dident send it and i was sleeping next to my sister that looked her name up on google and me and her both woke up and her laughter 2 hours later we hered carmen saying amanda.
i got a chain letter like two weeks ago about this girl.
carmen is still alive and none of that ever happend. i hate her and wished it did but it didnt. this is carmen now….to a comment a read earlier i do have nice tits.
well it is true u can believe or not cuz something like this cant just hapen it reals
Hey everyone. First, Shelby F. I’m so sorry about those mean girls. THEY should die. And think about it this Carmen girl pretty much died in a hole! Haha! And maybe she deserved to die! Ghost can’t even type much less ‘haunt’ you. So really. :/ and if Carmen is real I hope Toby dies.
Well that’s all. And if you are worried about her getting you, wouldn’t you know If some chick is pushing down a well. And if you REALLY are scared sleep in your parents or siblings room.
That’s all!!
-Madison :*
Oh one more thing, Carmen I’m an eight grader, and I’m not dumb enough to believe this crap. Fake-o!! Maybe you should… Get a life!!! Haha!
oh wait, you’re ‘dead’. Maybe you are better off dead. I mean, look how popular you are now.
your mean and i wish you were dead you probabley would be more popular dont you recon but if that sounded mean i sorry but you were mean and i’m only in stage 2 grade 3 and i’m not afraid to say it to and 8 grader
Hey carmen. I don’t believe any of this crap. I’m an eighth grade , I mean come on. maybe you should…get a life!!! Wait aren’t you dead!!!!?? Hahaha!!!! Well anyway maybe you are better off dead because look how popular you have gotten. And I would NOT have been your friend! Obvisiously if someones gonna make up a fake death, they are definitely UNpopular.
-Madison :*
sad!!!! hope she is better!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!+++++++++++++++@@@@@@@@@@@@$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
Omq!! is this true or wttt???
My sister never had that happen to her!
I’m sorry carmen you didn’t deserve to die please don’t hurt me r.i.p.
i don’t know why all you people are freaking out i have gotten that fwd like 20 times already and i haven’t sent 1 and im still here nothing ever happened to me but i do believe that she was pushed and that her story is true just not the part were you’ll die
Why are you all soooo scared of carmen i belive the story but not her comin to kill us i got tht tex 4 times and havnt sent them and im still alive
Have you dumbass had bad luck for not sending those txt…cause my boyfriend thought is not true either and now his laptop have viruses and i told him about bad luck…it true nobody dies but bad luck can happen..!!!!!! >:(
Naaaaaaah Waz up doc!
I beleive that carmen was pushed, but i am a little freeked out about the fwd thing! It is so creepy! Poor carmen has to have all this stupid talk to her name!
Exactly.. thats my wholee point, like no one comes back to life..thats just un-possible .. i jus got that text andd i went on a headd and google iht andd some of the sites said different so i really think the story is true but not whats going to happend to us if we dnt reply or send to other pplsx so.. to be honest this really dosent even makee sence.. but thats a shame how tje gurls did that
i feel srry for her if she really got pushed but i really dont think some 1 would silver up my toilet , pore out of my shower or come all the way from india to get me p.s it has been 6 years and there is only 1 death and it might not even b true
hey i feel so sad for her u now if 5 girls did that to me i would b going for them
OKAY I JUST WANT TO KNO 1 THING HOW CAN U EMAIL US WHEN UR DEAD I CANT C SOME 1 DEAD WHAKIN UP GETTING ON THE COMPUTER AND HAVE THETIME TO EVEN DO ANYTHING P.S IM NOT DEAD
OKAY I JUST WANT TO KNO 1 THING HOW CAN U EMAIL US WHEN UR DEAD I CANT C SOME 1 DEAD WHAKIN UP GETTING ON THE COMPUTER AND HAVE THETIME TO EVEN DO ANYTHING P.S IM NOT DEAD
LMAOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO amen
you guys ALL have issues, i wish you the best in life .
your so smart i totally agree
carmen was ushed thoses girls are lieinggg
5 12 1924 1058 156 4907! 5 2910 39514 102 96 694!
Hi… Sorry Carmen, if it is true, i am very sorry for what happened
Don’t worry, those girls will pay one day 
Also about the forward thing, i found one on facebook (on my home page, a friend must have put it there)… do i have to post it? if i dont, plz dont take me!!!!! Please i beg you, please!!!!
Guyz……. This is very true……. I have done many research and found out that who doesn’t believe her suffers……. So I believe in her……
its all fake but i only belive the part where she got pushed but the rest is fake
it so true! i sleep in my mommy’s room cus i so scared!
See was pushed
she got messed up
Poor carmen winstead was pushed down a sewer!!!!PUSHED!!!I cant believe someone would do that!!
Where was their teacher?
P.S. Some of you have horrible spelling and grammar skills. Please go back to school. If already enrolled, please pay attention in class.
whether it is true or not it is a sad story n cruel! bullying has become so pathetic, seriously i use to be a bully wats the point really, to hurt someone else’s feelings and make them feel low cause ur hurting inside n ur angry, as u get older n look back bullying is really stupid and there are alot of deaths associated with bullying that could be prevented by just doing somethin nice 4 that person of befriendin him/her school shootings happen cause of bullying, think of how many lives u could save n how good u could feel about urself by just standing up 4 that person or making that person feel as if there not alone. If Carmen Winstead did die i send my sympathies to the family n R.I.P Carmen. N if the girls did push her they all deserve wats coming to them. N for all u people that make smart comments on anothers death ur pathetic havent u seen the columbine high shooting or n e of them really time to grow up
This is not true I’ve seen this plenty of times its not true it’s fake and it’s fake
THIS IS SO FAKE
i believe the story but not the fwd but i sent it any way bc that stuff scares me so much and i dont know why but if it is true then rip carmen and if i was there i would defend u and carmen u sound really nice and not like the kind of peerson who would do that stuff so plz dont kill me
rip carmen
I believe in you carmen………
RIP carmen
Wtf I don’t know what to believe but if its true then them girls are mean and don’t have a hart if I was there I would of defended carmen she sounded like a nice gal but I believe that she got pushed
R.I.P carmen
my friend is scared to go to the bathroom cause of the txt
Hey everybody i think this is true ok!
ok every one on here said that the e-mail is not true ok for one who cares its not about the e-mail ok its about y she die every time u bully someone it really does get to them an most likely she was already thinkind about killin her self an no one cares now but when it happens to u then its a hole different story what if u picked on some one to day and the nextg day they dont show up at school and two weeks latter your techer stands in front of the class an says that person killed there self ok it might not be olny be cause of u but you had a hand in it to so most likely u have there blood on your hands same much as evey on eles that had a hand in it i no this cause im still goin throw it to this day an i think about it all the time so grow up an
think about what ypu do or say befor u do it an think how is that person goin to take it
Y’all are unbelievable. So easily scared. Carmen Winstead is fake. The whole story is fake. A group of four teenage girls made this up a couple years back just to see how many people they could scare. It’s hilarious how many of you believe this kind of bs. “RIP Carmen, please don’t kill me!” well now, how could she kill IF SHE WAS NEVER REAL?! Hmm? I hope y’all learned something from this. I have received this email and read it dozens and dozens of times, I HAVEN’T DIED YET! Wow, shocking, isn’t it? CARMEN WINSTEAD IS FAKE! Get that through your heads!
you guys just stop it is true and dont talk crap on her i acctualy have feelings for her and those five girls sooner or later are gonna die or pay for it sooo yeah and im sorry carmen!!!!
R.I.P Carmen
you guys just stop it is true and dont talk crap on her i acctualy have feelings for her and those five girls sooner or later are gonna die or pay for it sooo yeah and im sorry carmen!!!!
R.I.P Carmen
i believe that she was pushed
lmfao
i believe carmen was pushed yea but wat i dnt believe is that she came bak and killed off the ppl who didnt believe, wat about the poor girls parents hearing that her daughter came back from the dead and is killing her classmates, i feel sorry for them and carmen R.I.P carmen
I think she did get pushed, i belive her story and im against bullying i reposted it and everything so lets hope nothing will happen 2 me or my family !!! xx
i dont know but i dont lik thinking about it because when i think about it just makes it feel more real
i dnt know if to believe it or not im scared to take a showeer it says carmen will come and get me and i will wake up in a sewer unable to move and shell come and rip off my face is it true or not somebody plez tell me
plezzzz
plezz someone tell me!!!!
<3
hey im sorry that u died
Omg thats sooooo scary but she woont come back in the sewer i read it a long time agao and im still alive butt its still scary and i do belive it
That’s sad I feel bad for Carmen even know I dident know u u seemed nice we will all miss you I am sorry for you
I’m sorry carmen
hey i forward the message i belive in it and i am really sorry for you carmen winstead!!!!!!!!!!!
We beleive that this is nothing but a bunch of b.s. and not true so just get over it people nutin will ever happen to you.You guys are crazy if you beleive in this its not true damn it nothing will ever happen to you
I didnt send it and nothing fricken happend ppl need to just shut up and go on with the rest of there life and dont worry about those stupied txts
Has n e 1 one seen the person in question? (in real life), has she n e friends or relatives? if so dont u think they wud hav confirmed n e of these storys. i feel for this poor gurl even tho the events that may or may not hav taken place, And no 1 from the skool, family or friends hav commented or hav tryed to shut this or n e other site like this down. its ashame that thea r people out thea who get the kicks out of bullying other people. an IF n e of it is true i believe that the people who took part in the event got wat they deservd. As for the chain mail… well its pritty odvious isnt it.
I got that txt two years ago…and I’m still alive, they may have pushed her down and killed her, but I never forwarded it. And I’m still here and I’m 14 today
this story reminds me of pretty little liars:D
Ok if ur the rel Carmen I’ve gotten this fwd several of thinnest. Don’t get me wrong I fewd it. And I read it now I’m scared if I was there I would have helped u and I’m soo srry for u and all of ur loved ones bless u Carmen but don’t u think u should put a end to all of this crap? Well gtg Carmen srry bye… Please don’t kill. E I have plans for my life
i say she was pushed like why would they do that that is rude
This is ture Carmen was one of my best friends and now she is gone! Please dont bully someone like that she did not even live half of her life like we all are now.
They should be ashamed of themselves they shouldn’t of pushed her down the sewer. She really do seems like a really nice person. I really hope they went to jail for that or Carmen went back and got them..
please dont hurt me carmen, i tottly think this is true! but i actendly deleted it befor i could send it, sorry dont kill me;(
I am sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo scared now because that story seems scary and i feel really bad for her because that was soooo rude of the people who did that to her and i would so stick up to her if i knew her and if she was my besty forever because that is also sad. I feel soooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo bad for her.
Look you guys, I do believe this story, okay. But if you don’t at least think about not being rude about it she died in a gruesome and highly painful way, not to mention under the terms of humiliation! If you were to die like that and those who killed you didn’t own up, then yeah I would spread the word even if it wasn’t true, at least take it into consideration that you shouldn’t be so mean to those that do. Now, stop being jerks and just leave it alone if you don’t. (Hmph…. Stupid trolls)
Oh and Madison, shut the eff up, if you’re so popular why do you “waste” your time reading this?
I’m so sorry for u carmen plz don’t kill me I’ve sent it I’m only 10 I have a long way 2 go in life!!!!
“SHE WAS PUSHED”
I don’t know why all of you are joking about this. Sure some chainmails aren’t real, But have you ever considered the TRUE danger that may come?
there have been local news reports all around about some “chainmail” killer or something. so all of you should watch out…
This may be true but i have had enough of the broadcast on blackberry about it that someones going to haunt me if don’t broadcast that message. perfetic.