1. News & Issues
Send to a Friend via Email
You can opt-out at any time. Please refer to our privacy policy for contact information.

Discuss in my forum

David Emery

Dhimmitude in ObamaCare? No, It's a Politically Motivated Lie.

By August 29, 2011

Follow me on:

Dhimmitude in ObamaCare?

(UPDATED) Still proliferating at a rapid clip, a 2010-vintage smear campaign falsely asserts that Muslims are "specifically exempt" from the mandate to purchase insurance under health care reform legislation passed by Congress, declaring in all seriousness that it represents the establishment of Sharia (Islamic law) and "Dhimmitude" (subjugation to Muslim rule) in the good ol' U.S.A.  Read the details and the debunking here.


August 14, 2010 at 12:27 pm
(1) Bynor says:

I am pretty literate, but like usual we have elected lawyers to govern us, thus making it impossible to understand what is or is not fact because of the legal ease. So, is this real or unreal, only your lawyer knows for sure. I suggest that, like the bible, this language be deciphered into something the average person can understand. Then maybe, just maybe we can see how deep they have their hands in our pockets!

October 6, 2010 at 9:09 am
(2) Ddrummer says:

I’m sorry, but I’m currently on the floor laughing at Bynor’s comment…That laws should be translated into something understandable, like the Bible? Need he be reminded that it was ordered translated and organized by King James? Not only does it read in the Kings, (or in our era the Queens english), it was written for the benefit of “His majesty King James”. I’m not a lawyer but have read enough to know and learn for myself. What people really need is to get off their asses and do the same with our government. Stop waiting around for us to be handed something we understand. Stop waiting to be told what to do. Read the Constitution. Understand the fundamental rights that are outlined within it. Know that these things hold true for each and every citizen of this nation, natural or naturalized, then act upon it and accordingly. Read about the men and women of the Revolutionary war, about their struggles and exactly whom it was that fought for the freedoms we enjoy today. It wasn’t an enormous Army of the Government, it was an organized militia of ordinary people with extraordinary will. Read and learn how they suffered without boots and jackets in the dead of winter all along while England laughed at them only be defeated.

We don’t need something translated to that which we understand, it’s all right in front of us…It’s up to us to take responsibility of ourselves and learn for ourselves that which is being denied.

“if you don’t stand for something, you’ll fall for anything”.

January 27, 2011 at 10:23 am
(3) Joahannan bn Israel duBernays says:

The King James 1611 Bible was NOT written and organized BY or FOR King James. It was PERMITTED to be
printed by King James. The Error of making idiotic value judgements on rumors of the Actions and Behaviours of Aincent Cultures by 21 Century “values,” sgows You, sir, are Balaam’s Ass.
The King “Financed” the Bible English Translation as a Act of War Upon Spain, the Pope of Rome, and the ‘Destruction of the Spanish Armada” and the Spanish Defeat, resulted in the “Rise” of the Great British Empire. The 1611 Authorized Bible & the Catholic English Rheams/Douay translation were considered “TREASON against the VICOR of Christ” James would have been Burned at the Stake if England had not been victorious, the 1611 Bible, was Heresy, against ROME.

August 17, 2011 at 11:32 am
(4) Robert says:

This government is in the process of choking liberty to death by slow and continuous laws and regulations put into place. This trend is the very reason the founders put the Second Amendment in place. Read the first part of the Declaration of Independence and it states that when we get a government such as we have now have the populace is obligated to throw it off and re-establish the government under the intended original laws of the Constitution.

August 22, 2011 at 12:57 am
(5) Daniel Lotton says:

Simply Put Ddrummer

September 1, 2011 at 4:33 pm
(6) Kevin Tyler says:

And you should have added that Martin Luther did admit to putting some of his own beliefs into the King James Bible. Just do a search of him or better yet just look at wikipedia under his name.

October 2, 2011 at 8:35 am
(7) Urban Survivalist says:

Well said. Tired of all this BS rhetoric.

October 27, 2011 at 8:25 pm
(8) Rich says:

Here Here! I love the way you directly “Called Out” what is left of “We Americans” We All need to go back to our grade school history books and review what sacrifices it took the Revolutionary Army to eventually win against a most formidable British Army. Our schools no longer want to teach about American history, as I was taught in my youth. I am now 48 years old and cannot believe what they call “American History” in my three children’s schools. They receive a watered down version of our American history that barely creates an extremely light pink color for the red blood that was shed to create this America that we all enjoy! God Bless and save our Republic! And God Bless America!

November 19, 2011 at 6:42 pm
(9) Harmlessnut says:

not to be a gad fly but something to be aware of the ” doctrine of selective incorporation” does not necessarily guarantee all rights to the citizens within the state governments…this has no baring on you arguments regarding federal practices but it is a little known addendum to most assertions concerning the constitution… another aside the quote your ending on “those who stand for nothing will fall for anything” is largely attributed to Alexander Hamilton who was shot and killed in a dual standing for something…a simple case of theory v. practice

November 29, 2011 at 12:49 am
(10) Rudy Tidwell says:

Ddrummer: I would love to meet with you for awhile and discuss our varying viewpoints on God, the Bible and life! I feel sympathy for you because of you animosity toward God and things spiritual. I just want to affirm that God loves you and He offers to you a new life that is genuinely worth living. It is spiritual life that is made availaible to all who believe on and receive Jesus Christ as personal Lord and Savior. Before I yielded to Jesus Christ as my Lord, I had so many questions for which I could find no answers, and they bothered me a grat deal, but when I received Christ into my heart and life I received knowledge and wisdom far beyond what I had ever hoped or dreamed.

I comment you to Jesus right now in prayer as I comment Jesus to you.

August 23, 2011 at 5:39 pm
(11) John says:

That’s funny….you may be “pretty literate”…but you have no grasp of grammar or spelling.

The word you were looking for is legalese

September 8, 2011 at 10:07 am
(12) Mark says:

Also the term is “legalese” not “leagal ease”.

November 6, 2011 at 10:46 am
(13) Lorine Carroll says:

Dear Bynor:
I agree that the entire healthcare bill should be deciphered and re written so that everyone can understand it. Of course, that won’t take care of the problem, as so many will still twist the truth (as they do with the Bible) but it will make more people aware of the dangers hidden in the bill.

August 15, 2010 at 11:23 pm
(14) Dwight Brown says:

I wish Congress would pass a law that would make it contempt of Congress (more accurately contempt of constituents by congress) for a member of the House or Senate to vote on a bill before they have read it. Also all laws could be no longer than 100 pages and must be written at a 10th grade reading level.

September 24, 2010 at 5:22 pm
(15) robin says:

In reply to your statement, “must be written at a 10th grade reading level” If this is so the Government can actually understand what they are voting on it needs to written on a 1st grade level!! All our politician act like rich, spoiled, brats!!
Oh, wait! I forget they are RICH, SPOILED, and all act like BRATS!! Why don’t they cut their pay in half..stop getting a pension…if we have to put our hard earned money into a 401K plan, that will only end up failing because of our crappy Government..Why don’t they have to? They expect us to “trust” the banks with our money but they themselves do not. Hippocrates!! All of them.

October 5, 2010 at 3:06 pm
(16) Uncle Sam says:

I agree Robin. Why is it that the government officials get their vast pension plans while we, the real workers of America, get nothing! Do they put money into our 401K plans? NO! When companies are laying off workers, why are they adding more people in the government? We pay their salaries, yet we have no say in how it’s being spent.

September 18, 2011 at 10:56 pm
(17) Bart says:

I agree with you, Robin, but the word is “hypocrites.”

August 13, 2011 at 3:52 pm
(18) Bill says:

Dwight, I agree about the 10th grade reading level but keep in mind these bills are written by lawyers and in language crafted to enable legal discourse over it’s content. Just try and get 10 adults to read your post and give their intepretation of it. You will have 7 different viewpoints.

As to the 100 page requirement, you probably didn’t actually read the bill. I did, all 9 hundred something pages of it. It’s not written like a novel, it is in outline form with a lot of spaces and large margins, likely meant for annotation. The “thousand” pages sound bite proferred by the minority in Congress was just that, a sound bite. There are realistically less than 100 pages of business contract style documentation.

Assuming that you are an investor, look at a mutual fund prospectus the next time you get one. It is typically 75 – 100 pages with narrow margins and small type. Much more difficult to read (and understand) than this healthcare bill is.

September 4, 2010 at 10:38 am
(19) Robert says:

I personally believe you need to go lower than a 10th grade reading level…as this would include most of America if it were at the 4th or 5th grade level of understanding…most college kids cannot read at the 10th grade level, especially in State run colleges..

September 21, 2010 at 2:17 pm
(20) Betty says:

You could actually just attempt to read the bill rather than assume it’s impossible to understand. But wait, that would require actual work rather than just listening and believing whatever “enter random pundit’s name here” tells you. As a product of a public k-12 and college education, I can assure you that most students that are willing to put the time in can interpret this language.

October 7, 2010 at 10:24 am
(21) C says:

@ Ddrummer…..You could not be more accurate in your statements. Thank you.

October 8, 2010 at 10:41 am
(22) Chief Worm says:

Betty, I work in a field that reads and interprets “code” almost daily. This piece of “legislation” is an assault on sanity. I’ll admit that I haven’t read ALL of it if you admit it too. It is near impossible. To read it, you must refer to other laws/statutes/regulations. It is an outright Obozonation written as a convoluted, meandering and sometimes contradictory work of gibberish. And since it is not short, clearly written and forthright, it is and will always be open for interpretation of the ruling party. As my first Chief always said “KISS – Keep It Simple Stupid”.

October 19, 2010 at 1:48 pm
(23) linda says:

Ok, that still leaves the question, did he use the word “Dhimmitude” in the healthcare bill and if so in what context? How do we find out. I am new to all this but trying to learn.

October 19, 2010 at 2:47 pm
(24) David Emery says:


The word “dhimmitude” doesn’t appear anywhere in the health care bill. Why would it? The notion that it does is flat-out wacky.

My article contains a link to the full text of the bill. Search it to your heart’s content.

October 31, 2010 at 12:26 pm
(25) Ginger says:

David, you are correct. The word “dhimmitude” is not specifically stated in health care bill but, it certainly is implied. It is also noted that, that portion of the bill “has not yet been decided & won’t be for “some time”. Hello, somebody is buying time, hoping for a second term. If put into law now, it’s unlikely that would happen. Wake up America.

September 1, 2011 at 1:27 pm
(26) Elvis is Alive! says:

I think they’re just waiting for Obama’s second term to include the language “Any morons named Ginger are automatically excluded from any healthcare coverage and are subject to immediate judgement by a death panel”.

September 6, 2011 at 12:05 pm
(27) Mike Grunewald says:

Hey Elvis – none of these morons in office even know what they voted for. Most of the ;egislation falls under the heading of “vagueries to be determined for future considerations”.

Hence the chief moron Pelosi telling us all about the wonderful present we weer all given – “We have to pass the law so you can see what is in it”. I would love to know under what constitutional authority any represent can vote on a piece of legislation without reading the bill – much less understanding what they have read.

November 5, 2010 at 12:49 am
(28) DXL says:

I know most comments have been about whether or not the word dhimmitude is mentioned in the Bill, but I have one question. If this program is supposed to be good for us all, why is the congress, senate, and the president exempt? Hmm!

November 12, 2010 at 12:06 am
(29) Vanessa says:

As Nancy Pelosi says, “You have to pass the Bill so we can find out what’s in it”. This is absolutely pathetic! And she wants to now be the “Minority Leader”?

No, she should be fired!!!!

November 12, 2010 at 11:40 pm
(30) DXL says:

Vanessa, I totally agree with you!

November 19, 2010 at 6:23 pm
(31) Margaret says:


A facebook friend posted this link today. She is very RW and makes no bones about her dislike of the present administration and her hatred of Muslims. Trouble is she only read and posted the top part of the Snopes page. The copy of the email. And of course several people jumped on the bandwagon and ‘checked it out’ again only reading the email portion. If it were not so sad I would laugh. Now Snopes is not god I know but they have a pretty good reputation for sanity. If you take the time to actually READ the page you see there are various religious sects including the Amish that may be exempt for various reasons. So far it looks as though the Amish have the best chance of opting out. I found it interesting. Muslims however may not qualify because they do accept Soc.Sec (the Amish do not among other things) anyway it is a very enlightening page. Not the kind of enlightenment my friend found but then people who want to find the worst in/about people generally do.

December 12, 2010 at 11:19 am
(32) Reggie says:

A 28th Amendment (If a country truly believes in equality for all then any law that requires exceptions should never be allowed)

Section (1) of the 14th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution reads in part:

…“No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.”

An amendment as follows is needed for the federal government also. If you want to rein in an out of control Federal government this would do it.
A proposed 28th Amendment reads as follows:

Section I… “Any law passed by congress must apply equally not only to all citizens of the United States but also specifically and equally to members of congress and their staffs, the administrative branch and their staffs and the judicial branch and their staffs. Congress shall pass no law, the administrative branch shall not enforce any law nor shall the judicial branch make any ruling that gives special consideration to any individual, group of citizens nor any division of government at the national, state or local level, nor any organization however comprised, of the United States and that does not apply equally to all United States citizens.

Section II…Any previous actions by the congress, the administrative branch or the judicial branch that violate the provisions of section I of this amendment are declared null and void.

Section III…Any member of congress, the administrative branch or the judicial branch who violate the provisions of this amendment shall be impeached and barred from any further involvement in any capacity in the United States congress, administrative branch or the judicial branch for life.

December 18, 2010 at 5:40 pm
(33) Dolores says:

Reggie, most people have not read the Constitution and I’m sure Obama has not either. Most of Congress must be guilty of the same otherwise they would not want to pass this Healthcare bill. Who are we to believe??

September 1, 2011 at 1:30 pm
(34) Elvis is Alive! says:

Yes, I’m certain that a Constitutional Law Professor would never actually read the Constitution. Have you considered discontinuing drinking scotch with your cornflakes at breakfast?

September 4, 2011 at 12:58 pm
(35) Concrete Cowboy says:

So Elvisisalive. You are entitled to your own opinion, but are NOT entitled to your own facts. Barack Obama, the wrecking ball. was NEVER a Professor at any College or University. He was hired at the University Of Chicago as a political favor to use as an enabler to springboard to the Illinois State Senate. As I said, he was never a professor. He was hired to perform lectures on the Constitution. By the way, he did start his campaign for that election in William Ayres’ house. He wasn’t “just another guy in the neighborhood”, as Mao-bama claims.
When I, (and most people), read the Constitution we read it with the perspective of what WE can freely do. Mao-bama reads it with a negative viewpoint. He reads the Constitution with the perspective of what the government ca do TO US.

September 6, 2011 at 12:15 pm
(36) Mike Grunewald says:

A constituional law professor hopefully would understand the consitution. The empty suit in the oval office is not a constituional professor. If he ever did teach a course on the Constition, I feel sorry for anyone that sat through five minutes of one single class. The Constution is not a difficult document, yet the remedial understnading of not only the poser in chief, but Washington in general is a reflection on the progressive indoctrination that has been going on in this country at a steady clip for decades.

January 3, 2011 at 1:59 pm
(37) Dave says:

Reggie Rocks!! Whats good for the People is good for the Goverment!!! Over Paid, under worked Crooks!!! Impeach them all!!

February 18, 2011 at 10:41 am
(38) Kathy says:

I agree with this 100%. Throw the crooks out of the country after you,ve impeached them. They’ve created treason with their actions and don’t deserve to live here!

January 5, 2011 at 7:33 pm
(39) Margaret says:

@ Dolores…you must really enjoy Tea.

January 12, 2011 at 9:40 am
(40) Fred says:

There should be a law passed that before a new law can be put on the books, an old law has to be annulled and taken off the books. This would start cleaning up the pig pen.

January 25, 2011 at 8:57 am
(41) John Miers says:

Not only are members of Congress exempt from having to use Obamacare, any member, after they have been elected, can retire after only one term with full pay and benefits for life. Also, when they are first elected, they get over $1,000,000 for their office to use anyway they want. People, they have been sucking us dry!! If you really want change with these people then pass a law that will not let them receive money from lobbyist. Has anyone ever really asked where all those millions of dollars go?? How do they use that money?? Have the people that are asking all of these questions ever checked on their Congressperson to see how they vote on these issues?? By the way, Congress got raises last year, but Social Security people did not and the benefits of SS were lessen, A LOT. If they are going to have all these benefits, then why don;t they allow every American – legal Americans – be able to given one term in office so that they can retire with all the money and benefits. Now thats a socialistic state that would really make sense. Give everyone the same as the upper powers that be get.

January 26, 2011 at 4:02 pm
(42) Bill Weinberg says:

Reggie……I’m with you

January 28, 2011 at 9:36 am
(43) fair1day says:

This blog dude is a goof.


The real question is if a true muslim believes Allah will protect them.

February 18, 2011 at 9:46 am
(44) Mark P. says:

To find out if ANY word appears in the health care bill, go to http://www.opencongress.org/bill/111-h3590/text and then do a ‘control f’ (find) and in the find box type the word.

FYI, I’ve done it and ‘dhimmitude’ doesn’t appear in the bill. That does NOT mean that the concept or the effect of it isn’t there, but the word is not in the text of the bill.

March 28, 2011 at 10:42 pm
(45) qguy says:

Well, as Nancy Pelosi told us, they had to pass the bill so we could know what was in it. Now THAT’S assinine.

Oh, and by the way, the King James Bible is not “the Bible.” It didn’t just suddenly appear on the scene. It was a translation for its day, a “modern” translation of its time.

The original texts were written in everyday language, very accessible to anyone with even a rudimentary education (10th grade, anyone?) or even no education at all. What Christians call the Old Testament was originally written mostly in everyday Hebrew. The New Testament was written partly in Aramaic but mostly in Greek, and “street” Greek at that, not the high or formal Greek.

Today’s modern translations–and there are several very accurate and understandable translations available–are very understandable (as was the King James version to the average person in its day). If our laws were written to a standard even half us understandable to the average person as a modern translation of the Bible is today, our country would be much better off.

So please, let’s have no patronizing nonsense about the Bible being hard to understand. Some merely pretend it is for their own personal reasons.

June 26, 2011 at 4:12 pm
(46) Yankee says:

Basically I agree with the qguy.. However in the USA over the years each religious group has interprited the wording to suit their own needs of controlling their perishioners.

The Southern Bapist views are much different from the Northern Episcopalian ( and dare I say Northern Baptists) when reciting the same verses in the adult Sunday School and Bible Classes.

For years the ‘eye for eye’ groups shouted down the ‘forgiveness is required to get into Heaven’ groups.

A group of “men” decided what God wanted at Nicia. They translated and chose what ‘Books” would be in the Bible of that time. A Pope approved what was then ordered to be a Bible.

For Christians (what is down played ) it should be the Sermon on the Mount that guilds their daily life . If you believe in the words of Christ then pay heed to what was said by him. He said, according to those Scriptures, Pray in solitude, Forgive those who tresspass against you, as this is the only way into Heaven, HE taught the one prayer you need to live by…… Now that is “keep it simple stupid” …

March 29, 2011 at 1:25 am
(47) Jaime says:

I actually saw a modified copy of this chain letter e-mail in a local newspaper just recently. It’s telling that they printed a follow-up letter from a different person the very next day.

The fact is that it’s completely and utterly false in every respect. Muslims are just as culpable as Christians, Jews, Hindus, and whatever other religion one wants to name for buying health insurance under this law. They get no special exemption, they get no special privileges, nada, nothing.

The only people who can claim a religious exemption are those who are willing to completely bow out of it entirely (tellingly, only certain Christian sects have taken this exemption). Meaning they get no free lunch; no free health care on the taxpayer’s dime. And yet we still have people arguing that it’s dhimmitude, a term coined less than thirty years ago and which is still highly controversial.

Unfortunately, I know better than to hope that this dhimmitude rumor will die the death that it deserves; rumors grow with every telling and are almost impossible to kill. But the fact remains that this bill hardly represents some sort of legal servitude to Islam.

September 4, 2011 at 2:19 am
(48) Human says:

David Emery you are a democrat, that’s all I need to know.

You will craft the arguments in favor of the democrats.

September 4, 2011 at 11:10 am
(49) David Emery says:

You might want to give it just a little more thought than that.

September 20, 2011 at 12:20 pm
(50) Toomanx says:

It’s not that the bonehead that started this mail didn’t bother to do due diligence, they had an agenda.
If those who receive such garbage would even bother to invest the slight effort of pulling up H. R. 3590: The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act and do a “Ctrl F” search they would find it ain’t there.

People who perpetrate such corrosive lies are themselves being duped by subversive politics. The powers that want be count on this. Don’t you thing someone in the media would have jumped on this? It just goes to prove how gullible the general public truly is and how easily they can be led by the nose.

This discussion is meandering and needs to get back to the point. We are in trouble and listening to the man behind the curtain. He would like us to fuss among ourselves and not focus on the machinations obvious to a 10th grader from 1970. More proof of the failure of the education system an the unsettling portion of congress unable to read more than editorialized headlines.
Shut up, read more and vote intelligently or you may be learning Chinese soon.

September 26, 2011 at 2:36 am
(51) JustAcomment says:

You JUST declare that the circulating email referring to the word ‘Dhimmitude’ “falsely claims Muslims are exempt from U.S. health insurance mandate”, but DON’T BRING ANY PROOF of your claim. DEPLORABLE!! Bring the real quotation from the real text and THEN open a dialogue. NOT BEFORE you even know what on earth you are talking about. Don’t you realize that you are nothing but blabbing in vain…A SHAME that people like you are allowed to use the time and mind of others!

October 5, 2011 at 3:25 pm
(52) EmGee says:

You obviously did not bother to read the entire group of comments before going on your tirade. Also, how can you prove a negative?

December 12, 2011 at 4:10 pm
(53) kikorikid says:

Just read the language in the Bill, it does not specifically mention
Muslims BUT does allow for religious pro0hibitions against Insurance.
Guess what, Muslims have always had a proscription against insurance.
They view it as gambling. Also other than Muslims,Amish for example.

December 30, 2011 at 8:28 am
(54) Pay attention says:

The main street media reports ONLY what they want you to hear. They are in Obama’s pocket. Most of what you hear is twisted prophaganda.

February 2, 2012 at 11:18 am
(55) LA Resident says:

I believe the Obama Care will destroyed the economy and we need to get Obama out and all the other politicians that think the same and start over. The people are the government and we should stand up and fight this garbage that is being thown at us. Obama and the Republican candidates state the people of America want this.. I do not think they really know what we want. The average working american is struggling to stay afloat and the government is jsut pulling us down. It is time to regroup and start over and not destroy what our forefathers have started and built for us to carry the load in to the future

February 22, 2012 at 2:34 pm
(56) lovsbigsky says:

Fine, let the Muslims be exempt from ObamaCare…as long as they self-insure like the Amish, Hutterites and other religious sects do. When it’s all said and done, It will be interesting to see what “religious” groups’ qualify for the exemption.

March 6, 2012 at 3:24 pm
(57) Terri says:

Hi I think and feel we need to wake up America! Just how many more Lemons does it take for the American people to realize that Obama is killing all of us with his Muslim ways..He has a backer though his name is George Soro’s. George was with Hilter so he knows how to kill a country and bring it to its knee’s and he wants to kill all of us American’s, whats it going to take to get back all of our rights and to keep our homeland free of these kinds of people?We need to get him out while we can or we’ll be slaves by the end of his next term and all of our rights will be gone. WE will have another Civil-War in our own back yard for I refuse to give up my hand gun and I refuse to give up my freedom to live the way I wish to. The American People don’t need a lemon President telling us what to do or how to do it. To those that like him just wait until he takes away your freedom and places u in a prison or a work camp that they are building as we speak..

March 6, 2012 at 3:41 pm
(58) Terri says:

Hi one more thing I want all of you to look up George Soro’s he’s a scary man he has blood money and he’s not afraid to pull in others to do his bidding he owns most of the media and pays top dollar to get his views out there. Obama is his puppet he jumps when George tells him how high. George hired Obama to help run Acorn, George paid to get in office when he was running for Senator and now we have a new baby Hilter, stop and thnk about what Hilter did to all those people when he got in office. Hilter was after one blood line and used everyone to make a point and the cost was unreal..George lives in the states he was run out of England and he’s wanted in Russia and Germany so what does this tell ya..The American people fought hard to give us all what we all now have and we cannot let them throw all of us away like we are just paper we have to do something.. Obama doesn’t see the Native American people as fighters or even people to consider to do anything he finds all of us easy no matter the color, did ya know to that once he got in our homeland has more fighting among ourselves than we ever had? Did ya know that far away countries are laughing at us? We are no longer number one, if things cont to go the way they are we will no longer be the land of the free for our gov will soon have our of our kids brained washed and old folks in work camps, or waiting for all the old folks to die just like hilter did. How sad where is the back bone of our country? Stand up and be accounted for.We have folks fighting for our freedom that most take for granted we need to start doing our share.. Get off of unemployement find something to do don’t let Uncle Sam keep u in that pen he has built around you..Take what ya can find..Get off the grid..What if gas goes up to 12 a gal, what if the truckers no longer del food and med’s then what our gov is in control its time to break it..

March 7, 2012 at 11:59 am
(59) john says:

The mean comments about grammar all almost always left by ignorant idiots that only speak English, usually Americns because they are only taught one language at school unless they went to a private one. I would like to see any of these ignorant asses do as well as the ones they ridicule in the mother tongue of the ones they so freely correct. World travelers with a world view are a lot more forgiving, understanding and kind. Stick to the subject jackasses.

March 14, 2012 at 10:35 am
(60) Macksmart says:

I was going to participate in this “lively” spat, but you people are so self-righteous I figure you’ll just rip me a new you-know-what. Luck!

April 10, 2012 at 1:57 pm
(61) Ron says:

John wants us to learn another language before we may opine? And unless we are world travellers we are not forgiving, kind, etc. But he implies he is those things and observe how kind and understanding he is!! Most people would love to know other languages and be world travellers but just have not had the privilege to do so. Most people I know fit the latter and mostly they are kind, understanding, forgiving and loving. For the most part they are just a bunch of simple Christians that would welcome John into their midst in a heartbeat.

May 26, 2012 at 8:33 am
(62) Donk says:

For every “SmartAss Comment” there is always a “Smarter
Ass” out there somewhere!!!!!!

June 21, 2012 at 12:35 pm
(63) Louise Anne Zacek-Baker says:

If you’re serious? Please read the “ObamaCare” Act, which is more formally known as the ”The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (PPACA)” which does not contain the word “DHIMMITUDE” in it; nor does the Act exempt ANY people except the individual who is a member of a recognized religious sect exempted by the IRS or waived in cases of financial hardship. American Indians, for example, are exempt. (Old Order Amish, Mennonites, et.al. as approved by the IRS)

Next post: WHO is exempt… (coming soon in this blog near you!)

June 21, 2012 at 12:41 pm
(64) Louise Anne Zacek-Baker says:

WHO’S EXEMPT: (exerpts)

If you read IRS form 4029 (Application for Exemption from Social Security and Medicare Taxes and Waiver of Benefits)

Purpose of form. Form 4029 is used by members of recognized religious groups to apply for exemption from social security and Medicare taxes. The exemption is for individuals and partnerships (when all the partners have approved certification).

Who may apply. You may apply for this exemption if you are a member of, and follow the teachings of, a recognized religious group (as defined below). If you already have approval for exemption from self-employment taxes, you are considered to have met the requirements for exemption from social security and Medicare taxes on wages and do not need to file this form. You are not eligible for this exemption if you received social security benefits or payments, or if anyone else received these benefits or payments based on your wages or self-employment income. However, you can file Form 4029 and be considered for approval if you paid back any benefits you

Recognized religious group. A recognized religious group must meet all the following requirements:
• It is conscientiously opposed to accepting benefits of any private or public
insurance that makes payments in the event of death, disability, old age, or
retirement; makes payments for the cost of medical care; or provides
services for medical care (including social security and Medicare benefits).
• It has provided a reasonable level of living for its dependent members.
• It has existed continuously since December 31, 1950.


September 27, 2012 at 8:40 pm
(65) pj says:

Louise Anne, you’re the best!

October 6, 2012 at 5:06 pm
(66) kenneth pulomena says:

#1 seperation of church and state and some common sence

October 6, 2012 at 7:35 pm
(67) Ace Banger, The Guru says:

I to Shount believe in Insurance, ONLY when I gamble & ONLY if the dealer is shown Ace … Then even, then I dont always …
The Way to AVIOD this is SIMPLE …
Become what a Million Other Americans have become >>>
SOVEREIGN through GOD, deminion Over the earth & ALL IT Inhabs …
I TRUST my Judgement and ReAction Over that of The Actions of the NEGLIGENT !!!
P.S. Ddrumme … I believe that Bynor was saying that the bible to is hard to read, and it is for most until the breakthrough …

October 15, 2012 at 1:26 pm
(68) michael says:

look at it this way……it doesn’t matter who you vote for, ’cause once they get in office, they’re going to screw you anyway.

October 29, 2012 at 1:35 pm
(69) Cindy says:

I enjoyed every comment, especially the one where she wants us to prove a negative. Being an atheist, I’ve heard this from more than a few, “You can’t prove to me that there is no god.” DUH! A friend of mine who hated President Clinton insisted that he was trying to ruin the USA. When I asked her where he would live after he left office (and having to live on the lam from all those who would soon prove him a crook), she said “China.” Where is President Obama going to live with his family (he is, after all, quite young) when he is out of office and all these “assertions” come to pass? Some people can’t think for themselves; they let Fox News(?) do it for them. So sad, really.

November 4, 2012 at 1:28 pm
(70) Bob says:

To Cindy the atheist. A negative can in fact be proven, if of course it happens to be a reality, contrary to your evident assertion to the contrary. As far as where Obama could go once out of office I would suggest Kenya might be a nice place for him to reside. He has numerous family ties to that region if per chance you had forgotten. As to your assertion that [Sic] “…some people can’t think for themselves, so they let Fox News do it for them”, well just maybe you ought to try listening to Fox before you take someone else’s word for how they report the news. Evidently you’ve been educated in the Christ Matthews school of Leftist alternative realities (Do you too have a tingle running up your leg?)! Even though Fox might have a slight conservative (not Republican) bias, at least they make an attempt to offer the oppositions views for their listeners. The MSM’s myopic view of the news would only be exemplified by such news worth events as Fast and Furious and Benghazi. Fox had been reporting on them for two weeks before the Left even deemed it worth mentioning. Haven’t gotten much info about either one from the MSM have you? Go Figure!! You have heard of those events I hope. You know the old saying still holds true today for people such as yourself, ” Those Who Live In Glass Houses Probably Shouldn’t Throw Stones!” I would have to assume that evidently you haven’t been exposed to much of the truth about either one if you only partake of the Liberal Left Media such as MSNBC, CBS, ABC, or CNN. However in the meantime you might want to consider the saying, [Sic] “The problem with closed minded people such as yourself, is that it would appear your mouth spends much more time open than your mind”.

December 8, 2012 at 2:36 pm
(71) Vic_Brit says:

Will people please STOP pointing out that the bill doesn’t contain the word dhimmitude as though that somehow ends all debate?
It no more does so, than the Wannsee Minutes not containing the word the word ‘Holocaust’ , prove it wasn’t an entirely predictable outcome.

Moreover, the email itself NEVER even claimed that it did!
What it does claim,however, is that the bill appears to be smuggling a SIGNIFICANT ELEMENT OF DHIMMITUDE into US law.
quote:” Non-Muslims will be paying a tax to subsidize Muslims. Period. This is Dhimmitude”

The underlying theme of Western countries always having to make special exceptions to accommodate Islamist immigrants rather than vice-versa is also Dhimmitude, enforced by the Left as much as the [mainstream] immigrants themselves, esp. here in Europe.

Perhaps a more accurate description would be JIZYA – the Islamic tax (protection racket in reality) imposed on infidels, for the financial benefit of Muslims ,themselves, naturally., being exempt .

Seems to me only time will tell, but if IT IS possible for slimy lawyers to wrest exemptions, many will surely take advantage.
And if they are Islamists they will take enormous satisfaction and pride in doing so.

May 20, 2013 at 8:48 pm
(72) chuck says:

reggie – (32) add to sec. III that they should also forfiet any and all retirement benefits and any other freebiesotherwise given to retiring legislators/government workers.

July 6, 2013 at 4:51 am
(73) Jarrah says:

I have no comment on your health system except that is sounds very confusing, but I would like to take this opportunity to point a couple of things out to you Americans. I know you don’t like to admit that you may be wrong but please check the English dictionary for these two words: herb and aluminium. Why do you insist on dropping the ‘h’ from the word herb???

Aluminium is pronounced: al – you- min – i – um.
NOT ALOOMINUM, You leave out the second ‘i’ all together.

It helps with spelling if you pronounce a word correctly.

September 3, 2013 at 5:03 pm
(74) nicoleon says:

I’m with Ddrummer and Robert

November 4, 2013 at 4:21 pm
(75) Clayton Lane says:

I am a disable veteran , and it seems that every time I turn around the country that is was willing to die for seems to get further away from what is was meant to be, mostly thanks to congress most are nuts and the rest are just plain crazy , what the hell is going on ?????

November 4, 2013 at 4:24 pm
(76) Clayton Lanec says:

just to make a point again congress half of them are crazy the rest dumb

January 12, 2014 at 7:01 pm
(77) Gary Davis says:

Despite this debunking, it is true that most Muslims are not subject to Obamacare.

All a Muslim needs to do to opt-out is (a) not live in the United States and (b) not be an American citizen, and presto!, no Obamacare for you!

April 3, 2014 at 9:41 pm
(78) D Hip says:

So Muslims are not specifically exempted. BUT, it appears to me in reading the text of the law that they can legally request an exemption, in spite of their paying into social security. Insurance is a dirty word to Islam although they find it acceptable for their auto, which does have a measure of health insurance, if it is anything like our state in the issuance of registration of a vehicle. The wording of the law was pretty cagey, eliminating specific reference. There should be no religious exemption for anyone, period.

May 7, 2014 at 8:19 am
(79) Mike says:

There is no such word in the dictionary.

Leave a Comment

Line and paragraph breaks are automatic. Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title="">, <b>, <i>, <strike>

©2014 About.com. All rights reserved.