1. News & Issues

"MY CUP BOILETH OVER!" > Page 1, 2, 3

"He blew the door off his mother's microwave"
David writes:  I met a man who told me he blew the door off his mother's microwave oven when he boiled eggs. Fortunately, he was in another room when it exploded.

Whether urban legend or truth, the possibility of heated water exploding makes sense. When water is heated it changes from liquid to gas.

"A major cleanup job"
Tom writes:  Interesting topic! I had something similar happen.
About.com Poll
Has an incident like this ever happened to you?

Yes
No


Current Results
I used our new Sanyo microwave to heat a cup of water for 90 seconds at the highest heat setting (in our old microwave, this brought the water to just under boiling point). The water did not appear to be boiling but when I added a package of Liptons Cup-of-soup (I think it was Beef Vegetable), the water erupted like lava from Vesuvius, and flowed all over the counter and onto the floor. Very impressive! When it had stopped foaming, I had about 1/3 of a cup of soup left in the cup, and a major cleanup job.

Note the extensive use of detail....

"Never happened, never will happen"
M. Thompson writes:  Two problems with the view of the 'scientists' quoted in the article.

1) Convection will occur regardless of nucleation. Heating with microwaves occurs at some depth, not on the surface, therefore there will be convection, with subsequent cooling on the surface due to the air not being even close to 212 degrees F. This is just to point out that there can not be any superheated 'spots' within the body of the water. To accomplish that the liquid has to be in a weightless condition.

2) All water, except sterile water – boiled and condensed, has impurities in it; therefore boiling will occur with tap water or commercial bottled water – people don't like to drink sterile water because it is tasteless.

Conclusion: Never happened, never will happen in anyone's kitchen microwave oven.

There is a possiblity a ceramic cup could have a flaw in it and a small amount of water could become trapped in a small pocket. This water could turn to steam and eventually cause the cup to explode. Not likely but possible.

You really have to realize that just because someone has a PhD in a field such as physics, it doesn't mean that they are capable of thinking wholistically or practically – you know the old saw: knowing more and more about less and less.

"BOOM!"
Andy writes:  As usual, there is a grain of truth (or fear) in each legend. About 10 years ago – before Bill Nye and Ira Flatow – the NY Times had a science writer who was doing the PBS science show. He got great suggestions from parents, such as those who wrote or called asking if Wrigley's spearmint gum really gives off sparks? The questions were spurred by the bizarre behavior of kids who'd try to see the sparks in small groups in the closet. (It does. The mint, under pressure, lets off a flourescence, but the Wm. Wrigley company won't touch this one, he said.)

At a social gathering one evening we chatted about other funny science stories. He told about being on a morning local TV segment in L.A. and being prepared to demonstrate superheated water in the microwave. The experiment would be to heat pure water in a teacup for five minutes: it wouldn't be boiling. Then they'd put a teabag in and it would boil furiously.

His appearance on the morning show kept getting delayed, so they kept re-heating the water. Finally – BOOM! – and the door gets blown off the microwave. Needless to say, it freaked him out. The response of the TV producer: "That was cool. Can you do it again?"

I've wracked my brain to try to remember who the NY Times writer was, so that you could talk to him . . . but alas.

"Watch what you type in"
Dib writes:  I think you’ll find very few microwaves these days that don’t rotate the target. I’m pretty sure that the motion on imperfect rollers would be more than sufficient to jar the water enough to start steaming.

The place where this might cause trouble is should one not take care punching in the time to cook. It’s all too easy to hit 2222 in lieu of 222 when trying to heat a cup of water for 2 min. & 22 sec. (which on our unit makes the water hot enough for tea). If you don’t realize that the heat’s been on for ever you really might hurt yourself, even if the water does steam. Perhaps the "watch what you type in" advice is worth emphasizing.

> > Page 1, 2, 3  


Subscribe to the Newsletter
Name
Email


Current Net Hoaxes
Previous Features

Discuss in my forum

©2013 About.com. All rights reserved.