1. News & Issues
O'Hair vs. Religious Broadcasting
Part 2: Religious and patriotic fervor
 More of this Feature
• Part 1: The rumor that wouldn't die
 
 Related Resources
• O'Hair Confirmed Dead by Authorities
• Current Netlore
 
 Elsewhere on the Web
• FCC: Religious Broadcasting Rumor Denied
• Fighting a Myth of Biblical Proportions
• Will Phony FCC Petition Live On?
• Christian Urban Myths
 

What it lacks in accuracy, the petition more than makes up for in religious and patriotic fervor. As one would expect in a text that has been copied and re-copied so many times over by people who have no idea what the facts really are, this recent version features some odd and anomalous details along with the standard falsehoods:

  • It not only erroneously attributes the original FCC petition (already defeated in 1975) to the atheist O'Hair, it goes on to claim (again, erroneously) that the proposal was to ban all religious material from schools and airwaves — even Christmas carols.
  • Although the content and origin of the 1974 petition are thus completely misrepresented, the FCC docket number originally assigned to it (RM-2493) has somehow (one is tempted to say "miraculously") survived intact all the way down to this latest version.
  • Variants of the same text circulated two decades ago claimed the O'Hair's nonexistent petition bore the signatures of 27,000 anti-Christian backers. That number, already fictional at the time, has since been mysteriously blown up to 287,000.
  • We are asked to believe that one million signatures are needed to "defeat Ms. O'Hare [sic]" — a number clearly pulled out of a hat. There's a special irony in this: to date, the FCC has already catalogued no fewer than 25 million cards, letters and emails of protest regarding this moot issue.

Madalyn Murray O'Hair: Missing in action

Perhaps the most curious fact of all in the history of this misbegotten controversy is that, far from posing an ongoing threat to anyone's religious proclivities, Madalyn Murray O'Hair disappeared without a trace in the mid-1990s. As Time magazine recounted, "One day in August 1995, Madalyn, then 76, along with Jon, 40, and Robin, 30, vanished from the house on Greystone Drive, reportedly with breakfast still cooking, and were never seen again."  Evidently several hundred thousand dollars of American Atheists, Inc. money vanished with them, leading to all sorts of speculation as to the fate of O'Hair, her family and her fortune.

More recently she has been confirmed dead along with the missing members of her family, all victims of murder. On June 2, 2000 ex-convict Gary Paul Karr was convicted of participating in a scheme to extort money from the O'Hairs. Prosecutors alleged that Karr was also part of a kidnapping plot masterminded by former O'Hair associate David Waters, though jurors acquitted him of the charge.

In any case, publicity surrounding the 1999 arrests and subsequent prosecution of Waters and Karr generated a new surge in popularity for the FCC rumor in spite of the fact that all available evidence pointed to the likelihood of O'Hair being dead. What effect will confirmation of her passing have on its fate?  None. In its 25 years of existence, the FCC petition never had a whit to do with reality. Why should that change now?


Email This Article


Resources: Debunking the O'Hair petition

Religious Broadcasting Rumor Denied
Federal Communications Commission factsheet

O'Hair May Be Dead, But Will Phony FCC Petition Live On?
From the Baptist Standard

Urban Myths Within the Christian Community
From "Focus on the Family"

Fighting a Myth of Biblical Proportions
From the Washington Post, 26 Dec 2001

Position Statement on FCC Petition Hoax
American Atheists, Inc. calls the FCC rumor "a bald-faced lie."

Christinsanity Strikes Again!
Lengthy 1982 article from American Atheist magazine

FCC Phantom Petition Hits New York
1998 press release from American Atheists, Inc.


Current Netlore
The Urban Legends Top 25

Discuss in my forum

©2013 About.com. All rights reserved.